A Narrative Analysis Of Metaphor ReFantazio
“They were wracked by division…over the abstract, undefinable idea of ‘rightness.’ They tried to destroy something invisible and destroyed only themselves.”
We yearn for fantasy. We see it as a meaningful analog to reality. Into art forms of various mediums we stitch individual desires and perceptions of ours and others lives, both contemporarily and of bygone eras, across a complex tapestry of middle grounds, anecdotes and historical records. Immortalizing them in paper, canvas, film reel, or whatever blank slate of our preferred type. They inform, they contradict, they confront, and they live borne of the circumstances that make up our often unexplainable and unfair real world.
“You can call it a utopia, but I reckon people living in it might romanticize our world too.”
Metaphor ReFantazio is an artistic work from the core creative trio of director Katsura Hashino, character and art designer Shigenori Soejima, and composer Shoji Meguro at Japanese game developer Atlus. Best known for their work on Persona 3, 4, and 5 the trio use the structure of previous efforts as a base to work with, creating a brand new world that functions differently from our own while using many of the issues facing our real one as important texture and touchstones, creating something both familiar and distinctly its own all at once.
The Kingdom Of Euchronia is a medieval fantasy country inhabited by various races of anthropomorphous peoples, each with a key difference that makes them distinct from our own species. The horned clemar, the long-eared roussainte, the grey-skinned and white-haired rhoag, the winged ishkia, the bright-eyed and luminescent-haired nidia, the bestial paripus, the bat-like eugief, the three-eyed mustari, and the humanoid elda. Discrimination is rampant in Euchronia, wealth inequality is even more disparate than our own world with beggars constantly lining the streets of the Royal Capital. The State religion of the Sanctist Church finding them deserving of their fate and doing little to help the disempowered. With King Hythlodaeus V murdered at the hands of Royal Army General Count Louis Guiabern whose ideology closely aligns with social darwinism and dogmatic meritocracy, the country is plunged into a crisis of political tension and the physical threat of the disfigured monsters often attacking the people known as “humans” (yes you read that correctly). As the King had no known heir, through Royal Magic, Hythlodaeus’ will determines that in lieu of no successor, that there will be an open competition for the throne and that no one be excluded from the competition on grounds of tribe or social status if they wish to participate.
We inhabit the role of the protagonist. An elda boy and friend to the Prince, hidden son of the King, who himself years earlier in an assassination attempt was cursed by dark magic and forced into a long, seemingly endless slumber. Ultimately with the help of friends met along the way, deciding to stake his name for the throne while trying to find a way to break the curse on the dormant Prince. All while journeying across the continent, rallying support for his candidacy. Led along by a novel gifted to him in his youth depicting a utopian society that looks not too dissimilar to our world.
Each tribe has issues with other tribes that date back years before any of the respective populace for each were even born. And through each of our main characters, one from each tribe, we learn of the stereotypes and prejudices they have to endure through misconception and expectation. Strengthening the belief that Euchronia is a living place with history that informs its present. As an elda, the lowest of the low in Euchronian society as a result of being “tainted” with the inheritance of forbidden magic, you are often scoffed at, feared, looked down upon as you make your way across the continent.
Each of the main characters personal journeys are informed by the trials and prejudice they have had to face as a result of their experiences and socialization. Finding vindication amongst people of Santctism dedicated branding you as “pagan” for their tribe, finding the place to forgive oneself for their failure to protect the Prince, learning how to let their excitement of knowledge coalesce with a safe moral dignity. These are examples of small, compelling stories that add a sense of proof to what the artists want us to believe. And done so convincingly with consistently paced development at a believable speed and a balance of earnestness and consequences to keep their impact tangible.
The overarching narrative of the struggle for the throne is, as is often the case of Katsura Hashino’s style of story, is slow-paced and usually earns it’s time. Burgeoning, beckoning with mysteries and secrets that lie at the core of the world of Euchronia and it’s people. With the obstacles overcome finding a strong balance of both altruistic, and calculated to garner support of the masses. Fully believing in the change the group is trying to create in the world while also an acknowledgment that one cannot live fully without their own interests, mirroring the protagonist’s need for balance as a presumptive ruler. Making sure that they build up, rather than tear down in sync with their core beliefs. There are admittedly moments of moral obscurity within it’s writing both from a thematic perspective, and the foundation of its fiction bends over backwards a bit to accommodate it’s overall artistic vision, though in a game and story this size it is not easy to account for all of it’s flesh.
In Count Louis Guiabern a compelling antagonist who, along with genuinely believing he is doing his people a service with his hard-line meritocratic tyranny, has moments of understanding that both our struggles come from similar places with divergent methodology, that were the tables turned it could be you in his space and vice versa. That we were destined to be ideologically opposed. The manner in which he speaks, it’s no wonder he garners such a fervent support from the people ignorant of his true intentions. “Those in power exact the price of their greed from the people, then preach that such pain is a natural trial to overcome. An entire tribe does not become so derided to the point of genocide by authority figures alone, but by the vice of society in which that ignorance is born.”
Shigenori Soejima’s world and character art give the world a quality of faded dignity. The wear of the people, their hearts at their tipping point, a shading and sludge over their minds that anything could ever get better when they’ve only known one such way of living for such a long time. Shoji Meguro’s orchestral ballads and imposing death marches make for a soundscape that gives the impression that its people live in a feeling of impending doom at any given moment as the power structures both metaphorically and physically tower above them demanding their repentance to a maligned existence. The world weary exhaustion and moments of rebellion and misery seen and heard in illustration and melody.
The themes of meritocracy, systemic inequality, the impact of fantasy on societies lucky enough to experience it, and the anxieties of political upheaval, and how they are explore impart a clear and profound message. Even with the allure of fantasy and the places it can take us, we and those within the worlds we escape into would always choose to fight for the love, strength, and betterment of their world over one they know not of, over vague promises of unknown horizons. No matter how much better it may look or how appealing it may look for them to inhabit. It is their home, after all, and it is worth fighting for, rather than completely tearing at its seams. It isn't impossible to imagine the denizens of the worlds we create in art could see the scope of what we live in and love in as utopian comparatively and aspire to create echoes of what we have envisioned in theirs as a world worth striving for and building towards.



Comments
Post a Comment